About us
How we can help
Latest news
Press Releases
How to join
Contact us
Quick links
Church Society Trust
EV News

 General Synod Report 7 July 2008

Report on business from the General Synod at York University Monday 7 July 2008

First item of business was a progress report on the Anglican/Methodist Covenant.  The report usefully addresses some of the issues, including doctrinal matters, that remain unresolved between Anglicans and Methodists.  However, there did seem to be a general lack of enthusiasm in the debate which was commented on by more than one speaker.   It does no seem that some of the problems are going to be easily overcome.

The Parochial Fees Order 2008 passed without debate.  Unfortunately the person who had asked for it to be debated may not have been able to be present because the timing of the debate had been changed at short notice.

A motion for St. Albans Diocesan Synod was debated.  This motion, which was agreed sought to stress the value of work and encourage people to see work as part of their spiritual life rather than separate from it.  There was an unusual event in that an amendment was accepted by the proposer of the motion but then rejected, on an electronic count, by a narrow margin of only 3 votes.

In the afternoon the Synod began the debate on Women Bishops.  Due to the large number of amendments a total of six hours of debate was allowed going up to 10pm.  After the first four hours Synod had covered seven of the fourteen amendments. However, this represented the bulk of the difficult decisions.

The initial motion had been put by the House of Bishops which is sadly unrepresentative of the wider Church. Once they had put their motion it was going to be very difficult for any alternative to get through General Synod and this proved to be the case. Every amendment was voted on by houses and all bar one was lost. The motion that passed is important but not to do with provision.

The amendment which would have removed even a code of practice, so that there was no provision at all, was defeated but with over a third of the Synod voting in favour.

Motions which would have led to new Dioceses for those who cannot accept Women Bishops were defeated.

A motion from the Bishop of Leeds and Ripon which would have meant that the option of Transferred Episcopacy was explored in more detail for the February Synod alongside a code of practice was defeated in the House of Clergy.  However, the majority of Synod members did vote for this amendment.

The evening session began early at 8pm and went on until 10.15pm.  It became clear that a number of Synod members were aware that having disregarded what those seeking provision had said would be necessary they had created a problem and the tone of much of the evening was sombre.  An amendment was passed to ensure that the code of practice would be statutory.

At a late stage the Bishop of Durham attempted to get the motion adjourned, but this failed by a narrow margin.

The vote on the final motion, which was very much as put in the first place by the House of Bishops was then approved by all three houses.  However, once again, if this had been the Final Approval debate for the legislation it would not have gained the 2/3rd majority necessary in the House of Laity.

After the decision the Archbishop of York tried to say that the vote did not amount to a decision to kick traditionalists out of the Church of England. However, the fact that he said it indicates that is exactly how many will receive the decision.

Vote on the final resolution:

Bishops 28 - 12

Clergy 124 - 44

Laity 111 - 68


back to top

Related Links
Past News Reports
BulletPast News Reports
BulletNews 23 Nov 2010
BulletNews 24 Nov 2010
BulletNews 9 July 2010
BulletNews 10 July 2010
BulletNews 11 July 2010
BulletNews 12 July 2010
BulletNews 13 July 2010

BulletNews Jul 10
BulletNews Jul 11
BulletNews Jul 12
BulletNews Jul 13
BulletNews 9 Feb 2009
BulletNews 10 Feb 2009
BulletNews 11 Feb 2009
BulletNews 12 Feb 2009
BulletNews 13 Feb 2009

BulletNews 4 Jul 2008
BulletNews 5 Jul 2008
BulletNews 6 Jul 2008
BulletNews 7 Jul 2008
BulletNews 8 Jul 2008

BulletNews 11 Feb 2008
BulletNews 12 Feb 2008
BulletNews 13 Feb 2008
BulletNews 14 Feb 2008

BulletNews 6 Jul 2007
BulletNews 7 Jul 2007
BulletNews 8 Jul 2007
BulletNews 9 July 2007
BulletNews 10 Jul 2007

BulletNews 26 Feb 2007
BulletNews 27 Feb 2007
BulletNews 28 Feb 2007
BulletNews 1 Mar 2007

BulletNews 7 July 2006
BulletNews 8 July 2006
BulletNews 9 July 2006
BulletNews 10 July 2006
BulletNews 11 July 2006

BulletNews 6 Feb 2006
BulletNews 7 Feb 2006
BulletNews 8 Feb 2006
BulletNews 9 Feb 2006
BulletNews 15 Nov 2005
BulletNews 16 Nov 2005

BulletNews 8 Jul 2005
BulletNews 9 Jul 2005
BulletNews 10 Jul 2005
BulletNews 11 Jul 2005
BulletNews 12 Jul 2005


General Synod Pages
BulletSynod Latest

General Synod - Other Sub Issues
BulletAnalysis of reports
BulletNews Reports

Other Issues
BulletLocal Church
BulletNational Church
BulletAnglican Communion
BulletOther Faiths

 Issues Sitemap
 List all issues
 search church society
Bullet Click for advanced search
Home | About us | Publications | Store | Issues | Events | Press releases
Membership | Contact us | Search | Links | Churchman | Church Society Trust | Cross+way